SCHOOL LIBRARY JOURNAL (STARRED) — Gr 9 Up-The book opens with a 12-year-old girl named Erin having an incredibly vivid and confusing dream. She wakes up and starts her paper route. Because it’s November 1, there’s a lot of residual Halloween weirdness out on the streets, and soon she finds herself the target of some teenage boys who are wearing costumes while vandalizing the neighborhood. Erin is rescued by several newspaper delivery girls who are traveling together for safety, and then the narrative takes a surreal turn. Some folks in the neighborhood start disappearing, and people who appear to be wearing Halloween costumes seem to be from different times or places. The papergirls try to figure out who is attacking them and why, who are their allies or enemies, and just what on earth is going on. The tale ends with a striking cliff-hanger that will let readers know that the girls’ adventures are far from over. Vaughn’s reputation has already skyrocketed with the success of graphic novels like Saga, and this title helps to showcase his abilities as the author of far-out fiction that will make readers think. Colorful and captivating, the artwork expertly captures the strange qualities of this memorable outing. Strong language makes this more appropriate for mature readers. VERDICT An awesome selection for older teens and adults looking for an exciting sci-fi tale with unexpected twists.-Andrea Lipinski, New York Public Library

KIRKUS – “I loved that the book features four kick-ass girls on a wild adventure, and I think you will too. It reminds me a bit of The Goonies in that regard. When you look at those comic book shelves I mentioned a bit ago, you’ll see a lot of overly-muscled dudes fighting other overly-muscled dudes. Here, you have four very regular looking girls who I think will appeal to young and old comics readers out there.

Since this book is set in ‘88, there’s some language you might have to explain to your young readers, stuff that today wouldn’t be tolerated. I stumbled over a little of that simply because it’s probably been 20 years since I’ve heard it. But overall, I think this is a book you could enjoy yourself, or with your family.”